Alfano Law Office, PLLC

Alfano Law Office, PLLC
Phone: (603) 856-8411 • Fax (603) 290-5521
4 Park Street, Concord, NH 03301
  • Home
  • Real Estate Law
    • Road Law
    • Commercial Real Estate Law
    • Tax Abatements
    • Business Law
  • Estate Planning
  • About Us
    • Paul J. Alfano, Attorney
    • John F. Hayes, Attorney
    • David Howard, Attorney
    • Ariana Baldasaro McQuarrie
    • Privacy Policy
  • Articles
  • Contact Us
    • Directions
  • Road Law Guide
  • NH Tax Abatement
    • Tax Abatement Team
    • Grounds for Abatement
    • Municipal Application
    • Owners of Properties Outside New Hampshire
    • Transfer Tax Allocation
    • Recent Laws and Rulings
  • Resources and Links
    • Calendar and Key Dates
    • Equalization Ratio
    • NAPTA
Home » Blog » Appeal of Todd McIntire

Appeal of Todd McIntire

Wetland Council Decision Upheld – Beneficiary Lacks Standing to Bring Claim on Behalf of Trust

In a November 2022 order, the New Hampshire Supreme Court (the “Court”) affirmed a ruling of the New Hampshire Wetlands Council (the “Wetlands Council”), holding that a trust beneficiary lacked the requisite standing to maintain an action challenging the issuance of a shoreland impact permit.

The case in controversy began when petitioner Tanya McIntire (“Petitioner”) appealed a decision of the New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services (“DES”) granting Lake Ave Realty, LLC, (“Respondent’) a shoreland impact permit. The appeal was taken up by the Wetlands Council, which found that Petitioner lacked the standing to challenge the permit grant as Respondent is the beneficiary and not the trustee, of a trust that allegedly owns property abutting Respondent’s. Petitioner then promptly appealed the Wetland Council’s order to the New Hampshire Supreme Court.

In assessing Petitioner’s appeal, the Court first summarized its standard of review of Wetland Council decisions as set forth in RSA 541:13 (2021), which provides that Wetland Council findings of fact are to be deemed prima facie lawful and reasonable, and in order for a Council decision to be reversed, the petitioner must show that the decision was “clearly unreasonable or unlawful.” The Court explained that it must uphold decisions of the Wetland Council unless it can be shown by a clear preponderance of the evidence “that such order is unjust or unreasonable.” Id.

In relation to Petitioner’s standing arguments, the Court looked to RSA 21-O:14, I-a(a), III, which provides that in order to appeal a decision to the Wetlands Council, a party must be aggrieved by the underlying decision. The New Hampshire Supreme Court has held that persons aggrieved include any person directly affected by the challenged action or proceeding. Golf Course Investors of NH v. Town of Jaffrey, 161 N.H. 675, 680 (2011). To be considered an “aggrieved party” one must show a direct definite interest in the outcome of the decision. Id. It is not enough that one is simply a member of community. Id. Further, the Court pointed to the Restatement (Third) of Trusts § 107, which states that while a trustee may bring an action against a third party on behalf of the trust and its beneficiaries, generally a trust beneficiary does not have this same ability.

The Court found that Petitioner failed to demonstrate how her direct interests would be harmed by the decision to grant Respondent’s shoreline impact permit beyond that of any other member of the community in general. The Court also held that Petitioner failed to show any authority which would allow a beneficiary to maintain a case on behalf of a trust. As such, the Court found that Petitioner failed to demonstrate reversible error, and the Wetland Council’s decision was affirmed.

You can contact Alfano Law Office at (603) 856-8411 or at this link.

Filed Under: Court Updates, General

The above information is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Locations

Bedford

Concord

Keene

Portsmouth

Subscribe to the Alfano Law Property Rights Alert

Sign Up Now

For Email Newsletters you can trust.

NH Tax Abatement

  • Road Law Guide
  • NH Tax Abatement
    • Tax Abatement Team
    • Grounds for Abatement
    • Municipal Application
    • Owners of Properties Outside New Hampshire
    • Transfer Tax Allocation
    • Recent Laws and Rulings
  • Resources and Links
    • Calendar and Key Dates
    • Equalization Ratio
    • NAPTA

NH Real Estate Law Articles

  • Airbnb
  • Common Neighborly Legal Issues
  • Court Updates
  • Dealing with Neighbors
  • Easements
  • Estate Planning
  • General
  • Historic Designation
  • Legal Documents
  • Legal Terms
  • Legislation
    • Business Law
  • Living Trust
  • New Hampshire Property Tax Alerts
  • Private Road Maintenance
  • Private Roads
  • Property
  • Property Investments
  • Property Rights
  • Property Tax
  • Property Tax Law
  • Quieting Title
  • Real Estate Law
  • Revocable Trust
  • Road Law
  • Tax Abatement
  • Taxes
  • Zoning Boards of Adjustments

Recent Articles

Appeal of Town of Amherst

Housing Appeals Board Decision Affirmed by New Hampshire … [Read More...]

VT Telephone Co. v. FirstLight Fiber Inc.

Denied! Superior Court for the Northern District of … [Read More...]

What Is Road Acceptance?

(This is an excerpt from our Road Law Guide. To read more … [Read More...]

Why Developments Use Ponds to Prevent Stormwater Damage

If you have ever driven through newer developments, you may … [Read More...]

Article Archives

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Alfano Law Office, PLLC, 4 Park Street, Concord, NH 03301 USA | Phone: (603) 856-8411
Copyright © 2023 · Alfano Law Office, PLLC. All Rights Reserved · Website design by InterActive Synergy, LLC