Alfano Law Office, PLLC

  • ALFANO LAW WEBSITE
Home » Extraordinary Assumptions – a Handy Tool for Real Estate Appraisers

Extraordinary Assumptions – a Handy Tool for Real Estate Appraisers

Appraisers as Witnesses

Most real estate tax abatement cases heading to a final hearing require the testimony of an appraiser.  Two, in fact: one for the taxpayer, and one for the taxing authority.  Sometimes there is even a third appraiser. They will give their opinion as to the quality of one or the other reports prepared by the appraisers prior to the hearing.

People with specialized knowledge and skill in certain areas, such as the valuation of real estate, are permitted to testify at trials and hearings to assist the tribunal in rendering its decision.  The person first needs to be certified as an expert.  The court or board hearing the case usually makes that decision.

Experts have wider latitude to say things than other witnesses.  For example, if the appraiser relied on a report issued by a private research company in concluding the vacancy rate for the market area was X%, that information is hearsay.  The author of that report ordinarily would be required to testify.  This gives the other party and the court/board an opportunity to ask questions and test the quality of the conclusion.  An expert witness, however, may use such information.

But how far can an appraiser go?  Can an appraiser include his or her opinion on the cost to place a utility pole into the ground?  Possibly, if the appraiser is a civil engineer or otherwise has some suitable qualification.  How about the additional cost if poles must be drilled into bedrock?  Same answer.  But how about an opinion as to the amount of bedrock a utility likely will encounter in replacing the poles in a particular town?  This is where the use of “extraordinary assumptions” can come in handy.

Using Extraordinary Assumptions

If an appraiser represents that a particular material fact is true and accurate, then the appraiser must demonstrate how he or she came up with that fact.  They must also demonstrate how his or her qualifications make them qualified to develop that fact.  For example, if an appraisal report represents that 10% of replacement utility poles are likely to be placed in bedrock, and the appraiser is not qualified to make that statement, then that portion of the report is vulnerable to attack on that basis. If that portion of the opinion is critical, then the entire report and testimony may be excluded from the hearing.

On the other hand, if the appraiser relies on some other report for that information, and discloses that reliance as an extraordinary assumption he or she assumed to be accurate, then the appraiser should be fine.  The statement may still be challenged. However, the appraisal report itself should not be excluded based on the mere inclusion of the extraordinary assumption.

The upshot?  How information is disclosed can be as important as the information itself.

(Based on the March 12, 2018 New Hampshire Merrimack County Superior Court decision case in New England Telephone Operations, LLC d/b/a Fairpoint Communications NE v. Town of Acworth (220-2012-CV-100).)

You can contact the office here.

Filed Under: Property Tax Law, Real Estate Law, Taxes Tagged With: appraisers, expert, extraordinary assumptions

The above information is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

NH Tax Abatement

  • Road Law Guide
  • NH Tax Abatement
    • Grounds for Abatement
    • Municipal Application
    • Owners of Properties Outside New Hampshire
    • Transfer Tax Allocation
    • Recent Laws and Rulings
  • Resources and Links
    • Calendar and Key Dates
    • Equalization Ratio
    • NAPTA

NH Real Estate Law Articles

  • Airbnb
  • Common Neighborly Legal Issues
  • Court Updates
  • Dealing with Neighbors
  • Easements
  • Estate Planning
  • General
  • Historic Designation
  • Legal Documents
  • Legal Terms
  • Legislation
    • Business Law
  • Living Trust
  • New Hampshire Property Tax Alerts
  • Private Road Maintenance
  • Private Roads
  • Property
  • Property Investments
  • Property Rights
  • Property Tax
  • Property Tax Law
  • Quieting Title
  • Real Estate Law
  • Revocable Trust
  • Road Law
  • Tax Abatement
  • Taxes
  • Zoning Boards of Adjustments

Recent Articles

NH Supreme Court Mostly Affirms Enforcement of Ordinance Prohibiting Short-Term Rentals of Properties Unless Owner Occupied and Operated

New Hampshire Supreme Court Mostly Affirms Enforcement of … [Read More...]

NH Supreme Court Finds Plaintiffs Timely Perfected Appeal Despite Zoning Board Delay in Issuing Written Decision

New Hampshire Supreme Court Finds Plaintiffs Timely … [Read More...]

NH Supreme Court Affirms Decision to Uphold Declaratory Judgment on Ownership of Foreclosed Property

A three-justice panel of the New Hampshire Supreme Court … [Read More...]

What Terms Should Your Private Road Maintenance Agreement Include?

Private Roads in NH Series - Part II What Terms Should … [Read More...]

Article Archives

Alfano Law Office, PLLC, 4 Park Street, Concord, NH 03301 USA | Phone: (603) 856-8411
Copyright © 2023 · Alfano Law Office, PLLC. All Rights Reserved · Website design by InterActive Synergy, LLC